Dining Recommendations from the Staff at The Speckled Hen Inn
There is no shortage of great dining options in the Madison area. The following list is merely a sample and perhaps the first things that came to mind when we were asked about a specific type of restaurant. So, if you have other favorites or suggestions from friends, don’t hesitate to follow those leads. It’s hard to make an error in this city blessed with so many wonderful restaurants.
Our list is primarily made up of local, independent restaurants. If you were looking for a franchise restaurant Madison does have them all too. You will find everything from Ruth’s Chris Steakhouse to TacoBell here. But, try the local eateries. You won’t be disappointed.
The following are the Innkeepers picks based on our personal experiences and preferences in Madison.
The Old Fashioned
(608) 310-4545 23 North Pinckney St in Madison 53703
The best in Wisconsin fare – from burgers, fish fry, the spicy pickled egg, and THE best cheese curds anywhere. And more beers to choose from than you can count! Great atmosphere, fun and lively plus great food and service.
(608) 251-0500 Closed on Sunday and Monday
25 N Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703 Dress up and get ready for a great meal. The view of the Capitol is great. Seasonal menu features local ingredients. Great wine list.
(608) 441-1600 617 Williamson St in Madison 53703
Open for Brunch on Sunday but closed for dinner
Great atmosphere, food and service. Piano bar.
A Pig in a Fur Coat
(608) 316-3300 940 Williamson St in Madison
Closed on Sunday, Dinner 4-10 Monday – Saturday, No reservations
It is all about the food, beautiful food, and wine, and service!
Tornado Steak House
116 S Hamilton St, Madison, WI
A great downtown Madison Steakhouse with a Wisconsin supper club atmosphere.
128 E Wilson in Madison, (608) 255-8376
Dinner Mon-Sat 5-10pm No reservations
Cozy and relaxed spot serving large portions of seasonal Italian fare. Great wine list.
Cento Italian Restaurant
122 W Mifflin St in Madison, (608) 284-9378
Dinner Thur-Sat 4- midnight, Sun 4-8pm, Mon-Wed 4-10pm
Farm-to-table Italian style. Handmade pasta and wood fired oven producing roasted meats and pizza.
(608) 283-9500 131 East Mifflin St. in Madison
Dinner served 5-10pm Tuesday-Sunday
Old world ambiance and fine local ingredients prepared by their excellent chef.Asian cuisine interpreted by one of Madison’s favorite chefs.
(608) 257-6877 1128 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI 53703
They might have the best and most popular Friday Night Fish Fry in town. Favorites include the traditional beer battered fish, and the Door County fish boil.
(608) 273-4900 Stone House is closed on Sunday and Monday, Stable Grill is closed on Sunday
6261 Nesbitt Rd, Fitchburg, WI 53719
Be sure to visit the underground tunnel that leads to the wine cellar. Farmhouse atmosphere.
Red – Sushi
(608) 294-1234 316 W. Washington Avenue
Best sushi in town, small plates and large plate dinners
Dotty Dumplings Dowry
(608) 259-0000 317 N Frances St, Madison, WI 53703
BEST BURGER: There is NO need to go anywhere else!
(608) 442-6207 1201 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703
You will enjoy the look of this place, and the food and beer are great. One of those places where you feel instantly relaxed.
(608) 663-3926 2002 Pankratz St, Madison, WI 53704
Sandwiches, salads and pizzas are available until 10PM. Nice outdoor area in summer. Hoppy beers are brewed in sanity and it is easy to fall in love with their seasonal offerings.
Great Dane Brew Pub
(608) 442-1333 876 Jupiter Drive
They have several locations in the Madison area but this one has a relaxing view of the Capitol and a nice outdoor dining space.
Erin’s Snug Irish Pub
608- 242 – 7616 4601 American Parkway, Madison, WI 53718
Warm and fun atmosphere, good food and service. Nice Friday Fish fry and a really nice selection of beers.
Doolittle’s Woodfire Grill
(608) 729-4980 4323 East Towne Blvd in Madison
Woodfired rotisserie grill produces fantastic ribs but I love the parmesan crusted Walleye. Great food, wine list and outstanding service.
Buck & Honey’s
(608) 837-3131 804 Liberty Blvd., Sun Prairie (soon coming to Monona)
Local favorite, GREAT food, unusual combinations, upscale casual atmosphere, huge patio, live music, 16 craft brews on tap, specialty cocktails and an extensive wine list.
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies
(608) 318-1761 at 503 W Main St in Sun Prairie OR
(608) 238-6040 at 912 E Johnson St in Madison
We used to say that the best pizza in Madison was in Sun Prairie but then they opened a location in Madison. Happily, we are right between the two.
(608) 721-9100 3502 E Washington Ave Open Mon-Thurs until 9PMand until 10:00PM on Fri/Sat, 6pm Sun
Venezuelan and Latin American cuisine proving that things don’t have to be spicy to be full of flavor.
The Cooper’s Tavern
20 W Mifflin St in downtown Madison on the square
A great spot for lunch or dinner and they do have a late night (10- midnight) if you want to get desert or something more substantial after a show at The Overture Center.